An offer is more than a price
In a competitive market, the winning offer is rarely just the highest number. It is the one that shows the seller you are serious, prepared, and easy to work with. This guide covers the groundwork that makes an offer strong, the parts that go into it, and how compensation fits under the 2024 rules.
Start with your goals, build your must-have list, and let every part of the offer serve those priorities.
Know your goals before you buy
Why are you buying now? The answer shapes everything: the neighborhoods you consider, the homes you tour, and the offers you write.
- Upgrade to a home that fits your life better
- Downsize to less space and less maintenance
- Relocate for work or to be closer to family
- Stop renting and start building equity
- Get into a specific school district or neighborhood
Your must-haves checklist
Write down what you cannot live without before you tour. It keeps every showing honest and every offer focused:
- Bedrooms and bathrooms
- Garage size
- First-floor primary bedroom
- Yard or patio
- Home office
- Neighborhoods and school districts
- Price range and monthly payment comfort zone
The parts of an offer
Every offer is a bundle of terms, not just a price. Here is what goes into it and why each part matters:
Purchase price
The price you offer, shaped by recent sales, the home's condition, and how competitive the listing is.
Earnest money deposit
Typically 1-2% of the purchase price in this market, due right after acceptance and applied toward your down payment at closing.
Closing date and possession date
When the sale closes and when you actually get the keys, which matters for coordinating your own move.
Inspection period
Typically 10+ days to complete inspections and negotiate any findings with the seller.
Financing contingency
Protects your earnest money if your loan does not come through for a qualifying reason within the loan contingency period.
Items included or excluded
Which appliances, fixtures, and extras stay with the home, spelled out so there is no confusion later.
Seller concessions
Requests for the seller to contribute toward closing costs or the buyer's agent fee, negotiated as part of the offer.
Compensation options under the 2024 rules
Since August 17, 2024, buyer's agent compensation is negotiated in the offer rather than advertised in the MLS. Here are the common ways it works:
Seller concession for the buyer's agent fee
Request that the seller cover the buyer's agent fee as a seller concession in the offer. This is common in the Hamilton County market and often agreed.
Negotiate the price and pay separately
Negotiate a reduced purchase price and pay the buyer's agent fee separately. This can work when it makes sense for both sides.
A combination of both
Blend the two approaches: a seller contribution toward the fee, with the balance handled in the price or paid separately.
The fee is always the amount agreed in your Buyer-Broker Representation Agreement, never more, and any seller contribution reduces what you owe. Your agent walks you through the options before any offer is written.
How negotiation works
- The seller can accept, reject, or counter your offer; a counter is a conversation, not a rejection.
- A clean offer with fewer contingencies and strong earnest money can win over a higher price.
- Respond to counteroffers promptly, since hesitation can cost you the home.
- Approach the process as a collaboration: both parties want to reach closing.
Ready to build an offer that wins? Reach out to Susan anytime by calling or texting 317-777-9146, or book a free buyer consultation: book your consultation.
Buyer Agency: What Changed in 2024
The Buyer-Broker Agreement and how compensation works since August 17, 2024.
Closing & After-Closing Checklist
A 30-day closing timeline, the move-in checklist, and how to protect your loan approval.