Plum Creek Farms Neighborhood Guide
Late-90s and early-2000s homes set around the Plum Creek Golf Club off Hazel Dell. Here's what living with golf-course views really means.
Explore the Neighborhood
What kind of neighborhood is Plum Creek Farms?
Plum Creek Farms is a single-family neighborhood on Carmel's east side, built mostly between the late 1990s and the early 2000s off Hazel Dell Parkway near 126th Street. The defining feature is the Plum Creek Golf Club, a Pete Dye-designed course that the neighborhood wraps around, so many lots back right up to the fairways.
Homes mix ranch and two-story plans with three and four bedrooms on standard subdivision lots, and the HOA keeps ponds, cul-de-sacs, and walking trails in good shape. It is a less formal, more approachable version of golf-community living than the private clubs, and the price reflects that.
In short: Plum Creek Farms is for buyers who want golf-course ambience and a settled early-2000s neighborhood at a mid-market price.
Plum Creek Farms at a Glance
- Community type Golf-view HOA neighborhood
- Homes Late-90s & 2000s ranches & two-stories
- Amenities Golf course, ponds, trails
- Schools Carmel Clay Schools
- Setting East Carmel off Hazel Dell
What do Plum Creek Farms homes cost?
Plum Creek sits below the private golf communities but above Carmel's entry price points. Prices change with the market, so treat these as ranges, not quotes.
Price Range
Recent sales have clustered around the mid-$400s to mid-$500s, with larger golf-course-fronting homes going higher. Verify current listings for today's numbers.
Home Styles
Ranch and two-story single-family plans with three and four bedrooms, most with attached garages and open floor plans from the late-90s and 2000s building cycle.
Lot Sizes
Standard subdivision lots of roughly a third of an acre, with golf-course, pond, and cul-de-sac positions throughout.
What's around Plum Creek Farms?
Plum Creek Farms sits in the middle of east Carmel, near the Hazel Dell corridor and the county parks.
Parks and trails: Cool Creek Park's 90 acres, with the nature center, wooded trails, soccer fields, and playgrounds, are a short drive north, and the neighborhood has its own ponds and walking trails.
Shopping and dining: Retail and dining along 116th Street and Hazel Dell cover daily needs, with Midtown's City Center and the Arts & Design District a quick drive west.
Commute: Hazel Dell, 116th Street, and Keystone Parkway connect to I-465 and downtown Indianapolis, about 30 minutes away in normal traffic.
Plum Creek Golf Club's fairways run through the middle of the neighborhood.
Which schools serve Plum Creek Farms?
Plum Creek Farms is in the Carmel Clay Schools district, with attendance assigned by the district's east-side boundaries.
Elementary
The assigned elementary follows Carmel Clay's east-side boundaries, so confirm the current building for your exact address.
Middle
Students feed into one of Carmel Clay's middle schools (Creekside, Clay, or Carmel) by attendance boundary.
High School
Carmel High School, home of the Greyhounds, is the district's high school for grades 9 through 12.
Attendance boundaries can be adjusted, so always confirm the current feeder for your exact address with Carmel Clay Schools before you buy.
What's inside Plum Creek Farms?
Golf is the anchor, with a quiet, well-kept neighborhood around it.
Plum Creek Golf Club
A Pete Dye-designed course runs through the neighborhood, with many lots backing directly onto the fairways.
Ponds
Ponds are scattered through the neighborhood, giving water views and open space to many homes.
Trails & Cul-de-Sacs
Walking trails and quiet cul-de-sacs keep the pace slow and family-friendly.
HOA
An HOA maintains the common areas and appearance of the community. Confirm current dues for any property you consider.
Settled Streets
Twenty-plus years of mature landscaping give the streets a settled feel.
Location
Off Hazel Dell near 126th Street, with county parks and 116th Street retail close by.
What everyday life looks like in Plum Creek Farms
Golfers
A tee time is a short walk or cart ride away, without club dues on the scale of the private communities.
Families
Cul-de-sacs, ponds, and open space make it a safe, easy place for kids.
First-Time & Move-Up Buyers
Mid-market pricing and settled streets give buyers room to negotiate.
Commuters
Hazel Dell, 116th Street, and Keystone Parkway connect to downtown Indy in about 30 minutes.
Neighborhoods near Plum Creek Farms
If Plum Creek is close, these east Carmel neighbors are worth comparing too.
Brookshire
An established 1970s golf-course community with mature trees and its own pool, just south.
Read the GuideCherry Creek Estates
A settled family HOA with pool, clubhouse, and courts up the Hazel Dell corridor.
Read the GuideJacksons Grant
A large master-planned community with custom homes and a full recreation center, farther west.
Read the GuideAsk Susan about Plum Creek Farms
I know Plum Creek Farms well, including which lots front the fairways and how the HOA operates. Tell me what you're hoping for and I'll pull the homes that actually fit.
See homes for sale in Plum Creek Farms Book Your Plum Creek Tour Call or text 317-777-9146